Champagne’s Great Debate Is Not So Great

Rumors of rivalry between big houses and growers have been greatly exaggerated

Wine Spectator senior editor Alison Napjus
Alison Napjus, senior editor and lead taster for Champagne, highlights that both grower producer and big house Champagnes have merit on the market and in your glass. (Rick Wenner)

Alison Napjus, senior editor and lead taster for Champagne, explains the difference between the region’s récoltants-manipulants (grower producers) and négociants-manipulants (big houses) and why both business styles can produce top-shelf bubbly worthy of your time, consideration and enjoyment. Get the column from Wine Spectator’s Dec. 31, 2024, issue here!

Member-Only Content

Premium Subscription

Join today and get immediate access to this article, and to our entire database of more than 400,000 wine ratings. It only takes moments—but it will help you drink better all year long.

Start Free 30-day Trial

Already a member? Sign In

Try Winespectator.com Free for 30 Days!

Full access to our database of more than 425,000 wine ratings

Early access to reviews on our editors' favorite just-rated wines

Wine and food pairing tool,
chefs' pairing recommendations

Best value wines and winery intel

Subscribe today

You Might Also Like

Cheers to 2025

Cheers to 2025

Senior editor Mitch Frank predicts a new year of changing trends for the wine world

Dec 31, 2024
Wine Merchants Are Right That Tariffs Hurt Americans—Does Donald Trump Care?

Wine Merchants Are Right That Tariffs Hurt Americans—Does Donald Trump Care?

Restaurants, retailers and importers are gearing up for more trade battles, but the White …

Nov 22, 2024
Gigondas Blanc Est Arrivé!

Gigondas Blanc Est Arrivé!

One of the Southern Rhône’s most sought-after appellations premieres its new white wine

Dec 15, 2024
Williams Selyem Still Going Strong

Williams Selyem Still Going Strong

Winemaker Jeff Mangahas is a steward of quality and tradition at the Sonoma legend

Nov 30, 2024
A Breakout Vintage for Barbaresco

A Breakout Vintage for Barbaresco

A 2014 retrospective tasting reinforces the distinctive nature of this region’s Nebbiolos

Nov 15, 2024
Homecoming King

Homecoming King

Lucas Löwi returns to Argentina from Numanthia in Spain to showcase his homeland’s terroir

Nov 15, 2024